John S. Noyes, Tonawanda historical sketches, excerpt (History of the Lumber and Forest Industry of the Northwest, p354, George Woodward Hotchkiss, 1898.jpg
Dublin Core
Title
John S. Noyes, Tonawanda historical sketches, excerpt (History of the Lumber and Forest Industry of the Northwest, p354, George Woodward Hotchkiss, 1898.jpg
Description
The navigation of the lakes up to 1862 was almost wholly confined to side wheel steamboats and sailing craft, and these latter had little business in the rapid waters of the Niagara river except by the aid of tugs, whose charges for towing greatly reduced the profits of a trip, so that Tonawanda freights were not considered highly desirable. With the rapid extension of railroad lines west from Buffalo, the palatial steamers which for thirty years had increased in size, magnificence and numbers from year to year, became useless property and were laid up at docks at Buffalo and Detroit, to go to decay. Towing upon the lakes had to this time been confined to log rafts with perhaps an occasional perilous experiment of towing the hull of a new vessel from the point of her construction, to Buffalo or Cleveland to receive her rigging, but this involved sleepless nights on the part of her owners, until her safe arrival was assured.
In 1861 John S. Noyes purchased for a nominal sum, the hulls of the steamboats Empire and Sultana, former floating palaces, then sunken at Detroit, and fitted them up at an expense of several thousand dollars each, for the experiment of towing them, lumber laden, from the now rapidly developing lumber district of Saginaw, through lakes Huron and Erie to Buffalo. The average cargo of the Empire was 700,000 feet, and that of the Sultana about 500,000 feet, in contrast to the average vessel cargo of about 200,000 feet. The venture was looked upon with great suspicion not only by shippers, but by the insurance companies, whose agents saw, or thought that they could discern an extra hazardous risk in a vessel depending wholly upon even an extra large hawser or tow line to keep company with a steam tug, which perchance might have all she could do to save herself from the fury of the elements. These objections were, however, speedily demonstrated to be unfounded, and with the success of the venture, a new industry or enterprise was inaugurated. In 1862 the steamboat St. Lawrence was added to the line, and with her advent the writer of this history became associated with the firm as their agent at Saginaw. Other parties soon secured other of the old steamer hulls for a similar use, while a large number of sailing vessels which had reached an age when the strain of mast and canvas rendered them unseaworthy, were converted into tow barges. It was not long before the ordinary lake tug used for towing these craft gave place to steam barges, which not only towed from one to five other barges, but carried cargoes themselves, usually of a size the freight upon which paid a goodly proportion of the expenses of the round trip, and but a few years elapsed before sailing vessels practically disappeared from the lakes, their places being taken by towing and towed barges, while with the wreck or disappearance of the old hulls which had been extensively utilized at an early day, their places were taken by craft built expressly for the purpose, which with the increased demands of growing trade, have in later days been of from 1,500 to 4,000 and 5,000 tons burden, and the vast trade of the entire chain of lakes from Duluth at the head of Superior to the foot of Lake Erie, is now carried on by huge propellers, a majority of which have from one to a half dozen consorts in tow. And this reminds us again of the stranding of the “Flying Dutchman” in the swift currents of the Niagara river in 1856, which, perhaps, somewhat remotely to be sure, may be said to have been the first in the current of events leading to the remarkable developments of a later day, among which was the calling attention in 1865 to the desirability of Tonawanda as an adjunct and relief to the by this time plethoric condition of Buffalo harbor.
The lumber trade in Buffalo in 1897 was represented by the membership of its Lumber Exchange, which is as follows, viz.: Scatchard & Son, Mixer & Co., Haines & Co., Lee, Holland & Co., W. W. Brown, Hurd & Haughenstein, Noyes & Sawyer, E. D. Colie, Hurd Bros., Laycock Lumber Co., W. S. Crossthwaite, G. Elias & Bro., C. M. Betts & Co., Faust & Fleming, Holland, Graves & Montgomery, Palen & Burns, Superior Lumber Co., D. Y. Leslie, Hugh McLean & Co., Buffalo Hardwood Co., Empire Lumber Co., Taylor & Crate, W. W. Reilly, Underhill & Poole, G. W. Folger, Tindle & Jackson, James Fenton, Arthur Hill Lumber Co., L. P. Graves.
**TONAWANDA.**
Tonawanda is located on the Niagara river about ten miles from Buffalo, and on the direct line of the Erie canal, which was the important factor leading to its selection as a suitable place for the receipt and shipment of lumber to the east. The current of the Niagara river is too strong to render sailing craft available, but when the era of tow barging was inaugurated, and vessels were rendered independent of the wind through the medium of steam, the objections to delivering cargoes at points upon its banks had been surmounted. About 1866 Thomas W. Hotchkiss, a brother of the historian, and from 1847 a retail lumber dealer at New Haven, Ct., and later a wholesaler of lumber at Albany, subsequently operating at Elmira, New York, and as far west as Saginaw, secured a location at Tonawanda, and built docks for the reception of lumber and its re-shipment by canal. He was soon after followed by John S. Noyes and others, and the lumber trade at this point rapidly acquired large proportions, so that by 1873 the volume of receipts was represented by 221,076,007 feet of lumber, 23,249,000 shingles and 5,126,000 pieces of lath, and these proportions were practically held until 1880, when the volume had increased to 223,370,814 feet of lumber, 22,920,000 shingles, and 1,282,000 pieces of lath, increasing from year to year until in 1890, when a volume of 718,650,814 feet of lumber, 52,282,300 shingles, with 13,039,600 pieces of lath are recorded, this being the culminating point. During the twenty-three years between 1873 and 1896 we find record of 9,592,879,270 feet of lumber, 908,968,200 shingles and 170,908,450 pieces of lath as the sum total of receipts of lumber, lath and shingles at this point. Reducing the shingles and lath to lumber, and adding an estimated quantity of one billion feet as the receipts of the eight years from 1866 to 1873, and we may safely estimate the gross lumber receipts of Tonawanda at not far from 11,000,000,000 feet, and making allowance for errors and omissions in the reported statistics, we may safely say that the combined ports of Buffalo and Tonawanda have been the gateways for the home consumption and trans-shipment to the east of no less a quantity than 25,000,000,000 feet of the lumber product of the great northwest, in addition to vast quantities of cedar posts, telegraph poles and other products of the forest of which we have no means of arriving at the volume. With a rapid increase in volume, constant additions were the natural sequence to the operators at this point, and the present volume of business is transacted by the following named list of parties engaged in various branches of the trade, including wholesalers, retailers and commission dealers and shippers.
At Tonawanda—Eastern Lumber Co., Geo. H. Damon & Co., Cornelius Collins. North Tonawanda—Robinson Bros. Lumber Co., Geo. H. Sawyer Lumber Co., Skillings, Whitney & Barnes Lumber Co., H. M. Tyler & Co., Silverthorn & Co., Donough & Oliver, Dodge & Bliss Box Co., Oiele & McKean, A. Weston & Son, Willoughby & Hathaway, J. B. Huff, Calkins & Co., Fred Myrick, J. T. Charlton, Wisconsin Lumber Co., John Godkin, Muskoka Lumber Co., Kelsie & Gillespie, Rumbolt & Bellinger, Merriman & Merriman, Smith, Fassett & Co. As forwarders—W. H. Cowperth, P. W. Scribner, and Fassett & Bellinger.
In 1861 John S. Noyes purchased for a nominal sum, the hulls of the steamboats Empire and Sultana, former floating palaces, then sunken at Detroit, and fitted them up at an expense of several thousand dollars each, for the experiment of towing them, lumber laden, from the now rapidly developing lumber district of Saginaw, through lakes Huron and Erie to Buffalo. The average cargo of the Empire was 700,000 feet, and that of the Sultana about 500,000 feet, in contrast to the average vessel cargo of about 200,000 feet. The venture was looked upon with great suspicion not only by shippers, but by the insurance companies, whose agents saw, or thought that they could discern an extra hazardous risk in a vessel depending wholly upon even an extra large hawser or tow line to keep company with a steam tug, which perchance might have all she could do to save herself from the fury of the elements. These objections were, however, speedily demonstrated to be unfounded, and with the success of the venture, a new industry or enterprise was inaugurated. In 1862 the steamboat St. Lawrence was added to the line, and with her advent the writer of this history became associated with the firm as their agent at Saginaw. Other parties soon secured other of the old steamer hulls for a similar use, while a large number of sailing vessels which had reached an age when the strain of mast and canvas rendered them unseaworthy, were converted into tow barges. It was not long before the ordinary lake tug used for towing these craft gave place to steam barges, which not only towed from one to five other barges, but carried cargoes themselves, usually of a size the freight upon which paid a goodly proportion of the expenses of the round trip, and but a few years elapsed before sailing vessels practically disappeared from the lakes, their places being taken by towing and towed barges, while with the wreck or disappearance of the old hulls which had been extensively utilized at an early day, their places were taken by craft built expressly for the purpose, which with the increased demands of growing trade, have in later days been of from 1,500 to 4,000 and 5,000 tons burden, and the vast trade of the entire chain of lakes from Duluth at the head of Superior to the foot of Lake Erie, is now carried on by huge propellers, a majority of which have from one to a half dozen consorts in tow. And this reminds us again of the stranding of the “Flying Dutchman” in the swift currents of the Niagara river in 1856, which, perhaps, somewhat remotely to be sure, may be said to have been the first in the current of events leading to the remarkable developments of a later day, among which was the calling attention in 1865 to the desirability of Tonawanda as an adjunct and relief to the by this time plethoric condition of Buffalo harbor.
The lumber trade in Buffalo in 1897 was represented by the membership of its Lumber Exchange, which is as follows, viz.: Scatchard & Son, Mixer & Co., Haines & Co., Lee, Holland & Co., W. W. Brown, Hurd & Haughenstein, Noyes & Sawyer, E. D. Colie, Hurd Bros., Laycock Lumber Co., W. S. Crossthwaite, G. Elias & Bro., C. M. Betts & Co., Faust & Fleming, Holland, Graves & Montgomery, Palen & Burns, Superior Lumber Co., D. Y. Leslie, Hugh McLean & Co., Buffalo Hardwood Co., Empire Lumber Co., Taylor & Crate, W. W. Reilly, Underhill & Poole, G. W. Folger, Tindle & Jackson, James Fenton, Arthur Hill Lumber Co., L. P. Graves.
**TONAWANDA.**
Tonawanda is located on the Niagara river about ten miles from Buffalo, and on the direct line of the Erie canal, which was the important factor leading to its selection as a suitable place for the receipt and shipment of lumber to the east. The current of the Niagara river is too strong to render sailing craft available, but when the era of tow barging was inaugurated, and vessels were rendered independent of the wind through the medium of steam, the objections to delivering cargoes at points upon its banks had been surmounted. About 1866 Thomas W. Hotchkiss, a brother of the historian, and from 1847 a retail lumber dealer at New Haven, Ct., and later a wholesaler of lumber at Albany, subsequently operating at Elmira, New York, and as far west as Saginaw, secured a location at Tonawanda, and built docks for the reception of lumber and its re-shipment by canal. He was soon after followed by John S. Noyes and others, and the lumber trade at this point rapidly acquired large proportions, so that by 1873 the volume of receipts was represented by 221,076,007 feet of lumber, 23,249,000 shingles and 5,126,000 pieces of lath, and these proportions were practically held until 1880, when the volume had increased to 223,370,814 feet of lumber, 22,920,000 shingles, and 1,282,000 pieces of lath, increasing from year to year until in 1890, when a volume of 718,650,814 feet of lumber, 52,282,300 shingles, with 13,039,600 pieces of lath are recorded, this being the culminating point. During the twenty-three years between 1873 and 1896 we find record of 9,592,879,270 feet of lumber, 908,968,200 shingles and 170,908,450 pieces of lath as the sum total of receipts of lumber, lath and shingles at this point. Reducing the shingles and lath to lumber, and adding an estimated quantity of one billion feet as the receipts of the eight years from 1866 to 1873, and we may safely estimate the gross lumber receipts of Tonawanda at not far from 11,000,000,000 feet, and making allowance for errors and omissions in the reported statistics, we may safely say that the combined ports of Buffalo and Tonawanda have been the gateways for the home consumption and trans-shipment to the east of no less a quantity than 25,000,000,000 feet of the lumber product of the great northwest, in addition to vast quantities of cedar posts, telegraph poles and other products of the forest of which we have no means of arriving at the volume. With a rapid increase in volume, constant additions were the natural sequence to the operators at this point, and the present volume of business is transacted by the following named list of parties engaged in various branches of the trade, including wholesalers, retailers and commission dealers and shippers.
At Tonawanda—Eastern Lumber Co., Geo. H. Damon & Co., Cornelius Collins. North Tonawanda—Robinson Bros. Lumber Co., Geo. H. Sawyer Lumber Co., Skillings, Whitney & Barnes Lumber Co., H. M. Tyler & Co., Silverthorn & Co., Donough & Oliver, Dodge & Bliss Box Co., Oiele & McKean, A. Weston & Son, Willoughby & Hathaway, J. B. Huff, Calkins & Co., Fred Myrick, J. T. Charlton, Wisconsin Lumber Co., John Godkin, Muskoka Lumber Co., Kelsie & Gillespie, Rumbolt & Bellinger, Merriman & Merriman, Smith, Fassett & Co. As forwarders—W. H. Cowperth, P. W. Scribner, and Fassett & Bellinger.
Date
1898
Collection
Citation
“John S. Noyes, Tonawanda historical sketches, excerpt (History of the Lumber and Forest Industry of the Northwest, p354, George Woodward Hotchkiss, 1898.jpg,” North Tonawanda History, accessed November 21, 2026, https://nthistory.com/items/show/5109.

